Carrie Underwood Fans

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Fantasy Discs 3 & 4 (just for fun!)

Farawayhills

Well-known member
Call this greedy, lol - or just letting my imagination run riot - but I thought it might be fun to imagine if it had been possible to celebrate Decade 1 with a four disc collection.

Everyone would have their own choices - but what I've tried to do here is illustrate some of Carrie's less widely recognized stylistic range

Fantasy Disc 3 (Album Gems)

1. I Ain't In Checotah Anymore
2. Starts With Goodbye
3. Flat On the Floor
4. Get Out Of This Town
5. Crazy Dreams
6. I Know You Won't
7. Someday When I Stop Loving You
8. Songs Like This
9. Forever Changed
10. Thank God For Hometowns
11. Leave Love Alone
12. Cupid's Got A Shotgun
13. Wine After Whiskey

Fantasy Disc 4 (Non-album recordings & performances)

1. Because You Love Me (American Idol performance, round of the Top 16)
2. Independence Day (Post-Idol single release, Country "flip side")
3. Bless the Broken Road (Live, Carrie Underwood Stripped)
4. Praying For Time (Live, Idol Gives Back)
5 I'll Stand By You (Idol Gives Back, African video)
6. San Antonio Rose (Live, Grammy tribute, featuring Johnny Gimble & Ray Benson)
7. Desperado (Live, Grammy Tribute)
8. Alone (Live, I Heart Radio)
9. You're Looking At Country (Loretta Lynn tribute)
10. It Had To Be You (Tony Bennett duet)
11. Always On My Mind (Willie Nelson duet)
12. The Lonely Goat Herd (The Sound of Music Live)
13. Oklahoma Wind (Bonus work tape)
 
Disc 3 - The Ones That Should Have Been:
1. The Night Before (Life Goes On)
2. Starts with Goodbye
3. I Just Can't Live a Lie
4. I Ain't in Checotah Anymore
5. Flat On the Floor
6. Get Out of This Town
7. I Know You Won't
8. You Won't Find This
9. Twisted
10. Someday When I Stop Loving You
11. Songs Like This
12. Look at Me
13. What Can I Say
14. Do You Think About Me
15. One Way Ticket
16. Leave Love Alone
17. Wine After Whiskey

Disc 4 - Music Videos for All the Hits + New Ones for the Ones That Should Have Been! ☺️

Just my opinion. lol.
 
Oh! And put a live performance of Alone (doesn't matter which one), studio of I'll Stand by You, live performance of IKYW, live performance of Blown Away just because the studio version is too polished imo, and a re-recorded Inside Your Heaven to see what it sounds like now in there somewhere.
Wow, those really were fantasy discs 😂😂😂
 

tgbrinker

Active member
I'm not going to make a full 2 disc list, but this thread gave me the inspiration to whine for a second...

It's nearly inexcusable that Flat On The Floor, I Know You Won't, Songs Like This, and Wine After Whiskey weren't released as singles.
 

gocountrymusic

Active member
1.I Ain't In Checotah Anymore
2. The Night Before Life Goes On
3. Flat On the Floor
4. Get Out of This Town
5. You Won't Find This
6. I guess I kinda have to put I Know You Won't
7. Someday When I Stop Loving You
8. Songs Like This
9. What Can I Say
10. Do You Think About Me
11. Forever Changed
12. Leave Love Alone
13. Wine after Whiskey

Your fantasy Disc 4 seems perfect I might just add:
Acoustic Version of Just A Dream
The Walmart Soundcheck version of Jesus Take the Wheel
Grammy Mash-up of Blown Away and Two Black Cadillacs
Oh and Does He Love You with Jamie O'Neal
 

countrymusicfan15

Well-known member
Fun thread!

Disc 3:

1. This Time
2. Get Out Of This Town
3. Someday When I Stop Loving You
4. Songs Like This
5. Quitter
6. Lessons Learned
7. The Night Before (Life Goes On)
8. What Can I Say
9. Quitter
10. Do You Think About Me
11. That's Where It Is
12. Flat On The Floor
13. The More Boys I Meet
14. Wheel Of The World
 

countrymusicfan15

Well-known member
I'm not going to make a full 2 disc list, but this thread gave me the inspiration to whine for a second...

It's nearly inexcusable that Flat On The Floor, I Know You Won't, Songs Like This, and Wine After Whiskey weren't released as singles.

and Someday When I Stop Loving You, This Time, and Get Out Of This Town!
 

mtreasmith

New member
Disk 3:
1. Oklahoma Wind
2. Oklahoma Wind
3. Oklahoma Wind
4. Oklahoma Wind
5. Oklahoma Wind
6. Oklahoma Wind
7. Oklahoma Wind
8. Oklahoma Wind
9. Oklahoma Wind
10. Oklahoma Wind
11. Oklahoma Wind
12. Oklahoma Wind
 

carriefan14

Active member
Disc 3
1. Somethin' Bad feat. Miranda Lambert
2. I Know You Won't
3. Some Hearts
4. Paradise City (studio version)
5. Sweet Child O' Mine (studio version)
6. Is it Still Over? ( feat. Randy Travis)
7. It Had to Be You (feat. Tony Bennett)
8. Ever Ever After
9. Home Sweet Home
10. I'll Stand By You
11. There's A Place For Us
12. Sometimes You Leave

Disc 4 (Just in time for Christmas)
1. Do You Hear What I Hear
2. Last Christmas (studio version)
3. O Holy Night
4. What Child is This?
5. The First Noel
6. Hark! The Herald Angels Sing!
7. I'll be Home for Christmas feat. Elvis
 

carriefan0825

New member
disc 3:

1. the night before (life goes on)
2. i ain't in checotah anymore
3. you won't find this
4. someday when i stop loving you
5. songs like this
6. look at me
7. what can i say
8. do you think about me
9. forever changed
10. wine after whiskey
11. cupid's got a shotgun
12. somethin' bad

disc 4:

1. ISBY
2. praying for time
3. alone
4. go your own way
5. desperado
6. blue bayou
7. oklahoma wind
8- ~ LITERALLY ALL THE COVERS AND DUETS I CAN'T EVEN REMEMBER THEM ALL.
 
Disc 3 can have the singles that could and should have been....oh how badly I wish some of these were singles!

-Starts With Goodbye

-Flat On the Floor
-Get Out of This Town
-I Know You Won't
(this would make 8 singles total from Carnival Ride...LOL obviously unrealistic, but that's my favorite album of Carrie's. I think any and all of these 3 above have #1 hit potential)

-Someday When I Stop Loving You
-Quitter
(I feel that either of these choices would have been stronger singles than MS)

Strangely, I don't feel as passionate about BA's "should have been" singles...Perhaps Wine After Whiskey or Do You Think About Me? Maybe Leave Love Alone or Cupid's Got A Shotgun would sound good on the radio? Idk, none of these scream to me "I should have been a single!"
 

lizcarlo

Active member
3rd

1. Keep Us Safe
2. Wine After Whisky
3. Forever Changed
4. I Know You Wont
5. Flat On The Floor
6. Starts With Goodbye
8. Someday When I Stop Loving You
9. What Can I say
10. Good In Goodbye
11. Cupids Got A Shotgun
12. Thank God For Hometowns
13.Leave Love Alone
14. Dont You Think About Me

4th
1. Alone (I Heart or Fan Club Party)
2. Different Drum (Rock N Roll Hall Of Fame)
3. Paradise City ( fesival)
4. Sweet Dreams ( cover in studio)
5. Always On My Mind (Willie Nelson and Carrie Underwood duet)
6. San Antone Rose ( tribute to Brooks and Dunne)
7. You're Looking At Country (Loretta Lynn tribute)
8. It Had To Be You (Tony Bennett and Carrie Underwood duet)
9. Neon Moon (
10. Just A Dream ( Acoustic)
11. Remember When ( Alan Jackson cover at Opry)
12. Desperato ( Grammy Tribute)
13. Blue Bau ( I want Carrie to sing this solo in studio)
14. Oklahoma Wind (work tape)

Music videos of the songs on 3rd cd. Performances from the 4th cd. Interviews from Carrie talking about the songs she has written and why she wanted the other ones she didn't write.
 

Daydreamer81

New member
Not gonna list out any songs here but one of my favorite bands on their greatest hits had a fan vote for songs to be put on one of their discs. The choices included every song they ever recorded even ones that didn't make any of the albums. I think it would have been cool if Carrie had done something similar.
 
Top