Favorite singles in order

[Dibar]

Hi all! I don't typically post in here (I actually forgot my old account so just starting to now post with this one), I'm more of a lurker every now and then... but I've been extra bored lately and was curious, how would you all personally order Carrie's singles from your most to least favorite?

I apologize if this has been asked before. I checked, but I didn't find anything like this exactly. So please share! Hope it's fun for you guys to think through why you like certain songs above others... certainly a tough process... even though I love the message or story of certain songs, the music doesn't always do it for me as much as others, and vice versa.

Btw, I'm including inside your heaven as well as her duets. And..... GO!

1. blown away
2. good girl
3. something in the water
4. undo it
5. cry pretty
6. little toy guns
7. so small
8. just a dream
9. wasted
10. drinking alone
11. the fighter
12. see you again
13. mama's song
14. temporary home
15. cowboy casanova
16. last name
17. all american girl
18. remind me
19. i told you so
20. smoke break
21. love wins
22. don't forget to remember me
23. jesus take the wheel
24. before he cheats
25. dirty laundry
26. church bells
27. the champion
28. southbound
29. somethin' bad
30. two black cadillacs
31. heartbeat
32. inside your heaven

 

[pacarriefan]

This is hard but my top 10 at least would be:
Church Bells
Something in the Water
Temporary Home
Blown Away
Little Toy Guns
Just a Dream
Wasted
See You Again
Before He Cheats
Two Black Cadillacs

This kinda changes a lot too depending on the day!

 

[tgbrinker]

Here's a top 10...and a last place

Little toy guns
Church bells
Last Name
So Small
Smoke Break
See You Again
Blown Away
Wasted
Something in the Water
Two Black Cadillacs






Last: Mama's Song

 

[Dibar]

Looks like I have too much time on my hands but yeah I guess top 10 is more manageable.

For the record, I love all these songs... Some are in some ways more special to me than others, but Carrie does not disappoint.

 

[Zach1998]

So Small
See You Again
Church Bells
Something in the water
Wasted
Temporary Home
Two Black Cadillac’s
Dirty Laundry
Blown Away
Just a dream
Little toy guns


Southbound
Don’t forget to remember me
Heartbeat
Before he cheats
Smoke break
I told you so
Jesus take the wheel
Drinking alone


All American girl
Cowboy Casanova
Good girl
Last name
Love wins
Cry pretty
Mamas song
Undo it
Inside your heaven (I don’t really consider this a single so I’ll put it last)

I separated it in three tiers. Tier one is phenomenal, tier two is very good, tier three is ok definitely not bad, just don’t return often.

 

[lizcarlo]

Favorites:

Cry Pretty
Jesus Take The Wheel
Blown Away
Smoke Break
Drinking Alone
Something In The Water
Little Toy Guns
Just A Dream
Wasted
Temporary Home
Last Name
Before He Cheats
Don’t Forget To Remember Me
Dirty Laundry
Church Bells
Two Black Cadillac’s
I Told You So


I like these but is not favorite:

See You Again
So Small
Mama Song
Cowboy Casanova
All American Girl
Love Wins
Good Girl
Heartbeat


These are just okay:

Undo It
The Fighter
Something Bad
The Champion
Southbound
Inside Your Heaven

 

[liz278]

My favorites:
•Something in the Water
•Wasted
•Temporary Home
•I Told You So
•Church Bells
•Blown Away
•Little Toy Guns
•Cry Pretty
•So Small
•Drinking Alone
•See You Again

Like:
•Good Girl
•Just a Dream
•The Fighter
•Cowboy Casanova
•Last Name
•All American Girl
•Remind Me
•Love Wins
•Don't Forget to Remember Me
•Jesus Take the Wheel
•Before He Cheats
•Dirty Laundry
•The Champion
•Southbound
•Somethin' Bad
•Two Black Cadillacs

Least favorite:
•Undo It
•Mama's Song
•Smoke Break
•Heartbeat
•Inside Your Heaven

If I were to hear any of her songs on the radio or streaming on Spotify I would not turn it off. On my Apple Music I have all of my favorite songs and a bunch of her songs that never made it as a single. Also when I am at her concert there isn't a song I don't sing along with.

 

[NC State Carrie Fan]

Favorites:
Something In The Water
Church Bells
Cowboy Casanova
All-American Girl
Good Girl
Blown Away
Undo It
Last Name
Remind Me
Jesus Take The Wheel

Strongly like:
Heartbeat
Two Black Cadillacs
Mama’s Song
So Small
Before He Cheats
Wasted
Southbound
The Champion

Good:
The Fighter
Somethin Bad
See You Again
Just A Dream
Little Toy Guns
Smoke Break
Cry Pretty
Drinking Alone

My least favorites:
I Told You So
Temporary Home
Don’t Forget To Remember Me
Dirty Laundry
Love Wins
Inside Your Heaven

 

[CU4ever]

Favorites:
*in no particular order
- Heartbeat
- Smoke Break
- Blown Away
- Jesus take the Wheel
- Remind Me
- Mama's Song

Decently Like:
*in no particular order
- Something in the Water
- So Small
- Two Black Cadillacs
- Cry Pretty
- Drinking Alone
- Church Bells
- Before He Cheats
- Southbound
- The Champion
- The Fighter
- Just a Dream

Good:
*in no particular order
- I Told You So
- All American Girl
- Good Girl
- Wasted
- Somethin' Bad
- Inside Your Heaven
- Little Toy Guns
- See You Again


Least favorite:
*in no particular order
- Undo It
- Last Name
- Cowboy Casanova
- Love wins
- Dirty Laundry
- Don't Forget to Remember Me