listen I LOVE carrie but lets get real, it would be too boring, shes too nice. It just be like when AI got ellen, everyone loves them but they are just to soft-no backbone.
on the other hand Kelly I have no idea why she hates idol so much and talks bad bout it always, she would be perfect, and yeah miley does sound cool and she DOES have experience I mean the gril has been touring since she was 14 years old and has done it all, talented or mediocre, she would be a great judge for the younger contestants, now for the older why not faith hil or Alicia Keys?