Carrie Underwood Fans

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rank the songs

x0xJeSSx0x

New member
Good Girl
Blown Away
Who Are You
Cupid's Got a Shotgun
See You Again
Two Black Cadillacs
Good in Goodbye
One Way Ticket
Nobody Ever Told You
Leave Love Alone
Wine After Whiskey
Forever Changed
Do You Think About Me
Thank God for Hometowns



That was difficult.
 

Louisa

Well-known member
Louisa's Song Ranking List

I have tired my best to rank each song in order. I have to say Wine After Whiskey is probably my favourite song on the entire album. This list may differ as time progresses! :)

Wine After Whiskey
Thank God For Hometowns
Good In Goodbye
See You Again
Leave Love Alone
Good Girl
Blown Away
Cupid's Got A Shotgun
Two Black Cadillacs
Nobody Ever Told You
Forever Changed
Do You Think About Me
Who Are You
One Way Ticket
 

bigbluegrl23

Active member
Two Black Cadillacs
One Way Ticket
Blown Away
Good Girl
Do You Think About Me
Cupid...
Leave Love Alone
Wine and Whiskey
Forever Changed
Nobody Ever Told You
Who Are You
Good In Bye
Sea You Again
Thank God For Hometowns

However, I still love all of them haha
Becca
 

Burst

Well-known member
Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs
See You Again
Good Girl
One Way Ticket
Do You Think About Me
Cupid's Got a Shotgun
Wine After Whiskey
Who Are You
Good in Goodbye
Nobody Ever Told You
Leave Love Alone
Forever Changed
Thank God For Hometowns

That's really hard... I love love LOVE Leave Love Aloe and it's 3rd last. That just shows how good this album is. It's awkward putting Good Girl in here. It could go annywhere from 3rd-8th to be honest.
 

Zman312

Active member
This is hard for me to list them just yet. I won't give my review or rank until I have a physical copy...lol, but my TOP THREE at the moment are:
Two Black Cadillacs
Wine after Whiskey
Blown Away (Love the subject matter and the chorus, GREAT STORY, this is slowing moving up, before it wasn't even in my top 5)
 

cole

New member
Blown Away - (I really can't stop talking about this song - probably will for years and years)
Forever Changed - I literally had this song on repeat all of last night, I love it more and more each time I hear it)
Who Are You - (There's just something so unique about it; I love the "You're in my thoughts, you know my mind" part)
Good in Goodbye - (I can really, really relate to this song)
Wine After Whiskey - (So hard to choose GIG and this one! I love the opening and closing guitar)
One Way Ticket - (Hate that this one is so low on the list, I love it. but they are all so good!)
Do You Think About Me ( So sweet!)
Nobody Ever Told You (What a great song for Carrie, hope this is a single)
See You Again (This one makes me so happy)
Two Black Cadillacs (I'm eagerly hoping many, many people will get to hear this)
Leave Love Alone ( A fun song!)
Thank God for Hometowns (A good one, but not really necessary on the album)
Good Girl (who would've thought the first single would be one of the weakest songs on the album?)
Cupid's Got A Shotgun (I don't think I even listen to this; just press the skip button, after hearing it 4 times).
 

supercarriefan

New member
As of right now (and this is subject to change lol):

Forever Changed
Thank God for Hometowns
Leave Love Alone
Cupid's Got A Shotgun
Two Black Cadillacs
Do You Think About Me
One Way Ticket
Blown Away
Wine After Whiskey
Good in Goodbye
Nobody Ever Told You
Who Are You
See You Again
Good Girl

GG is last because we've had it the longest and it isn't as fresh for me as others at this point. All the songs are so close, even the last songs on the list are favorites in some way. I'm loving the more emotional songs right now because I feel like Carrie is so invested in conveying the stories. Every time I listen to TBC, I debate how they killed cheating husband lol...right now, I'm going with poison :p.
 

Zman312

Active member
Blown Away - (I really can't stop talking about this song - probably will for years and years)
Forever Changed - I literally had this song on repeat all of last night, I love it more and more each time I hear it)
Who Are You - (There's just something so unique about it; I love the "You're in my thoughts, you know my mind" part)
Good in Goodbye - (I can really, really relate to this song)
Wine After Whiskey - (So hard to choose GIG and this one! I love the opening and closing guitar)
One Way Ticket - (Hate that this one is so low on the list, I love it. but they are all so good!)
Do You Think About Me ( So sweet!)
Nobody Ever Told You (What a great song for Carrie, hope this is a single)
See You Again (This one makes me so happy)
Two Black Cadillacs (I'm eagerly hoping many, many people will get to hear this)
Leave Love Alone ( A fun song!)
Thank God for Hometowns (A good one, but not really necessary on the album)
Good Girl (who would've thought the first single would be one of the weakest songs on the album?)
Cupid's Got A Shotgun (I don't think I even listen to this; just press the skip button, after hearing it 4 times).

I disagree with you on TGFH because I think it goes perfectly with the album, especially since the cover references "The Wizward of Oz"

GG is a not the weakest, yes it's similar to her pervious songs but it's edgy and definietly a good song. Also the lead sinle doesn't have to be an dmost of the time is not the STRONGEST SONG on the album. I think GG is doing it's job!

Cupid's Got A Soutgun is a good song but it's just too redneck for me (sorry!)
 

Sofa Critic

New member
I love the album from beginning to end, but here is my ranking based on 8 to 10 spins:

Two Black Cadillacs
Wine After Whiskey
Cupid's Got a Shotgun
Blown Away
Good Girl
One Way Ticket
Leave Love Alone
Good In Goodbye
Do You Think About Me
Forever Changed
Thank God For Hometowns
Nobody Ever Told You
Who Are You
See You Again
 

allamericangirl8

New member
The bottom two or three I'm not feeling now that the novelty has worn off.

Two Black Cadillacs
Forever Changed
Cupid's Got a Shotgun
Do You Think About Me
Wine After Whiskey
Good Girl
Leave Love Alone
Who Are You
One Way Ticket
Blown Away
See You Again
Good in Goodbye
Nobody Ever Told You
Thank God For Hometowns
 

sgabe_15

New member
Do You Think About Me
Good in Goodbye
Wine After Whiskey
Two Black Cadillacs
One Way Ticket
Good Girl
Blown Away
Forever Changed
Nobody Ever Told You
Leave Love Alone
See You Again
Thank God For Hometowns
Cupid's Got a Shotgun
Who Are You
 

Casper

New member
1 - Blown Away
2 - Two Black Cadillacs
3- Cupid’s Got a Shotgun
4 - Wine After Whiskey
5 - Good Girl
6 - Thank God For Hometowns
7 - Good In Goodbye
8 - See You Again
9 - One Way Ticket
10 - Do You Think About Me
11 - Leave Love Alone
12 - Forever Changed
13- Who Are You
14 - Nobody Ever Told You
 

Claire2004

Active member
As of right now (and this is subject to change lol):

Forever Changed
Thank God for Hometowns
Leave Love Alone
Cupid's Got A Shotgun
Two Black Cadillacs
Do You Think About Me
One Way Ticket
Blown Away
Wine After Whiskey
Good in Goodbye
Nobody Ever Told You
Who Are You
See You Again
Good Girl

GG is last because we've had it the longest and it isn't as fresh for me as others at this point. All the songs are so close, even the last songs on the list are favorites in some way. I'm loving the more emotional songs right now because I feel like Carrie is so invested in conveying the stories. Every time I listen to TBC, I debate how they killed cheating husband lol...right now, I'm going with poison :p.


This is why I disagreed with the Slant review lamenting about the lack of details on TBC. For me, songs that leave out some details are just as interesting as the detailed ones. On TBC it makes the listeners speculate what happened, how thay did it, etc.
 

allamericangirl8

New member
I'm almost positive they poisoned him. How else could they both be killing him without ever seeing each other? For two months, no less.

Unless there was a third party, a hitman, but that would be too risky. It's a secret that he was even murdered in the first place. If there was a hitman, people would already know a homicide was committed, and there would be an investigation, and those two would undoubtedly be prime suspects. And if they find evidence of the hitman, they can't trust this third party to keep silent. It's just a dumb idea.
 

Cps235

New member
1. Good Girl
2. Blown Away
3. Two Black Cadillacs
4. Do You Think About Me
5. One Way Ticket
6. Thank God for Hometowns
7. Who Are You
8. Wine After Whiskey
9. Nobody Ever Told You
10. Forever Changed
11. Leave Love Alone
12. Cupid's Got a Shotgun
13. Good in Goodbye
14. See You Again
 

ramb

Active member
Let's see if it's possible...

Blown Away
Good Girl
One Way Ticket
Two Black Cadillacs
Good In Goodbye
Cupid's Got A Shotgun
Wine After Whiskey
See You Again
Leave Love Alone
Who Are You
Do You Think About Me
Nobody Ever Told You
Thank God For Hometowns
Forever Changed

"Blown Away" is a masterpiece. I really LOVE the lyrics, it tells you a whole story with just saying a few words. That's the magic it has.
"Good Girl" just blow me away when I heard it, Carrie's vocals are amazing. And it's the best lead single she has released, after JTTW.
"One Way Ticket" is the kind of music I never thought Carrie would sing. It's ZacBrownBand-vibe is just incredible. I love it.
 

carriecountrystar

Active member
Boy, sure was hard ranking one over the other when they all overlap over each other from time to time.


1. Two Black Cadillacs
2. Wine After Whiskey
3. Good In Goodbye
4. See You Again
5. Forever Changed
6. Do You Think About Me
7. Blown Away
8. Good Girl
9. Who Are You
10. Cupid's God a Shotgun
11. Thank God for Hometowns
12. One Way Ticket
13. Nobody Ever Told You
14. Leave Love Alone
 

micah6vs8

Member
1. WAY best song ever!
2. OWT love it
3. SYA
4. BA
5. TBC
6. GG
7. WAW
8. NETY
9. LLA
10. CGAS
11. DYTAM
12. TGFH
13. GIG
14. FC

The top 10 are all great, last 4 not so hot.
 

BlownAway

New member
1. Good In Goodbye
2. Wine After Whiskey
3. Who Are You
4. Blown Away
5. Two Black Cadillac's
6. See You Again
7. Do You Think About Me
8. Forever Changed
9. Good Girl
10. Thank God For Hometowns
11. Leave Love Alone
12. One Way Ticket
13. Cupid's Got A Shotgun
14. Nobody Ever Told You
 
Top