Carrie Underwood Fans

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rank the songs

allamericangirl8

New member
New!

Two Black Cadillacs
Forever Changed
Do You Think About Me
Cupid's Got a Shotgun
Wine After Whiskey
Leave Love Alone
Good Girl
One Way Ticket
Good in Goodbye
Blown Away
Who Are You
See You Again
Nobody Ever Told You
Thank God For Hometowns

I'm still not feeling NETY or TGFH, though NETY is really cool live.

Slight changes.

Two Black Cadillacs
Forever Changed
Wine After Whiskey
Do You Think About Me
Leave Love Alone
Cupid's Got a Shotgun
One Way Ticket
Good Girl
Good in Goodbye
Blown Away
See You Again
Who Are You
Nobody Ever Told You
Thank God For Hometowns
 

daqman

New member
1. Blown Away
2. Good in Goodbye
3. Two Black Cadillacs
4. Good Girl
5. See You Again
6. Who Are You
7. Forever Changed
8. Thank God For Hometowns
9. Wine After Whiskey
10. Do You Think About Me
11. Nobody Ever Told You
12. One Way Ticket
13. Cupid's Got a Shotgun
14. Leave Love Alone
 

Burst

Active member
Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs
See You Again
Do You Think About Me
One Way Ticket
Good Girl
Cupid's Got a Shotgun
Wine After Whiskey
Who Are You
Good in Goodbye
Leave Love Alone
Nobody Ever Told You
Forever Changed
Thank God For Hometowns

Now:
Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs
See You Again
One Way Ticket
Do You Think About Me
Good Girl
Wine After Whiskey
Who Are You
Good in Goodbye
Cupid's Got a Shotgun
Nobody Ever Told You
Leave Love Alone
Forever Changed
 

CarrieFan928

New member
My new ranking:
1. Blown Away (+3)
2. Good in Goodbye (+1)
3. Thank God For Hometowns (+4)
4. Two Black Cadillacs (+5)
5. Do You Think About Me (-4)
6. Good Girl (-1)
7. See You Again (-5)
8. Nobody Ever Told You (+2)
9. Wine After Whiskey (-1)
10. One Way Ticket (-4)
11. Leave Love Alone (+1)
12. Who Are You (-1)
13. Cupid's Got a Shotgun (=)
14. Forever Changed (=)

NEW:
1. Blown Away (=)
2. Thank God For Hometowns (+1)
3. Good Girl (+3)
4. One Way Ticket (+6)
5. Two Black Cadillacs (-1)
6. Wine After Whiskey (+3)
7. See You Again (=)
8. Do You Think About Me (-3)
9. Good in Goodbye (-7)
10. Cupid's Got a Shotgun (+3)
11. Leave Love Alone (=)
12. Nobody Ever Told You (-4)
13. Who Are You (-1)
14. Forever Changed (=)
 

Wildflower

New member
Better late than never :eek:

1. Blown Away (11/10) PERFECTION. So glad this is the title track! One of her best ever.
2. Good Girl (10/10) Sassy, sexy, and catchy as hell! Good choice for the first single.
3. Do You Think About Me (9/10) A sweet country love song that makes me smile, so sweet.
4. Leave Love Alone (9/10) Love the twang and the southern roughness to it.
5. Two Black Cadillacs (8/10) Eerie and brilliant all at the same time. Best lyrics on the album, very visual.
6. Wine After Whiskey (8/10) This song is filled with soul and emotion, it really touches your heart.
7. Forever Changed (8/10) This one is a heart breaker, not as great as TH but still a very solid song.
8. Cupid's Got A Shotgun (7/10) By far the most country sounding track, its silly and super catchy.
9. Nobody Ever Told You (7/10) Wasn't a huge fan at first but it has grown on me, good message.
10. See You Again (7/10) Hard to evaluate cause it was meant for Narnia, but it has grown on me as well.
11. One Way Ticket (6/10) Not a fan of it at first because it sounds like a Jason Mraz song (no disrespect) but I can appreciate her branching out and trying new things.
12. Good In Goodbye (6/10) A little too sleepy, I don't have a real connection to this song.
13. Thank God For Hometowns (6/10) Another sleepy one, not too memorable for me.
14. Who Are You (5/10) I'm a Christian, just not a fan of this song.
 

teesharky

Well-known member
1. Do You Think About Me
2. Wine After Whiskey
3. Blown Away
4. Cupid's Gotta Shotgun
5. Leave Love Alone
6. Good Girl
7. See You Again
8. One Way Ticket
9. 2 Black Cadillacs
10. Good in Goodbye
11. Thank God for Hometowns
12. Forever Changed
13. Nobody Ever Told Me
14. Who Are You

I love all the songs though-- so don't think there are any "Mama's Song" situations here on this album for me. lol I even like the ones at the bottom. I just don't love them as much. lol
 

carebearcarrie

Active member
1. Blown Away
2. Forever Changed
3. Who Are You
4. Two Black Cadillacs
5. Good In Goodbye
6. Do You Think About Me
7. One Way Ticket
8. Good Girl
9. Thank God For Hometowns
10. Nobody Ever Told You
11. Leave Love Alone
12. Wine After Whiskey
13. See You Again
14. Cupids Got A Shotgun
 

xboom28x

New member
1. Two Black Cadillacs
2. Blown Away
3. Good Girl
4. Leave Love Alone
5. See You Again
6. Good In Goodbye
7. Wine After Whiskey
8. One Way Ticket
9. Nobody Ever Told You
10. Cupids Got A Shotgun
11. Who Are You
12. Do You Think About Me
13. Forever Changed
14. Thank God For Hometowns

It feels wrong to rank One Way Ticket so low, but I just love all of the songs above it more! It's crazy how good this album is!!

Now:

1. Two Black Cadillacs
2. Leave Love Alone
3. Good Girl
4. See You Again
5. Blown Away
6. Nobody Ever Told You
7. Wine After Whiskey
8. One Way Ticket
9. Good In Goodbye
10. Who Are You
11. Do You Think About Me
12. Cupid's Got A Shotgun
13. Forever Changed
14. Thank God For Hometowns

I see that she is performing Leave Love Alone in England and Australia. I really hope it gets released as a single!
 

luvebug99

New member
1. Good Girl
2. Thank God for Hometowns
3. Leave Love Alone
4. Two Black Cadillacs
5. Good in Goodbye
6. Wine After Whiskey
7. See You Again
8. Blown Away
9. Nobody Ever Told You
10. One Way Ticket
11. Do You Think About Me
12. Who Are You
13. Forever Changed
14. Cupid's Got A Shotgun
 

Carrieflattsfan

New member

1. Two Black Cadillacs
2. Blown Away
3. See You Again
4. One Way Ticket
5. Wine After Whiskey
6. Forever Changed
7. Good In Goodbye
8.Do You Think About Me
9. Thank God For Hometowns
10. Cupid's Got A Shotgun
11. Good Girl
12. Nobody Ever Told You
13. Leave Love Alone
14. Who Are You


That was hard! The only one I'm not loving is "Leave Love Alone," but it's already growing on me. I honestly can't say there's a bad song on the album; each has its own distinct placement. I LOVE "Thank God For Hometowns; at first I was surprised it wasn't getting more love, but I've realized it's got a niche of its own. Some people just can't relate to it the way those of us who grew up in small towns can, which is understandable. This album really does have something for everybody. I'm kinda ashamed to say I completely overlooked "Good In Goodbye" the first time I listened to the album; it's one of the best ballads she has ever done. "Who Are You" is also beautiful; I overlooked this one on the first few listens, but Carrie's vocal and passion is amazing here. Her vocals are so refined and pristine on every track; it's hard to believe she has never had any vocal training, because she's learned to work with her voice so well in such a short time.

I can't wait to give BA a proper listen on my Ipod tonight; I honestly don't think this record will ever burnout for me; it's amazing. I've already listened to it at least 10-15 times and I think there's so much variety it feels fresh everytime.

New:
Two Black Cadilacs
Blown Away
Wine After Whiskey
Do You Think About Me
Good Girl
Good In Goodbye
Forever Changed
See You Again
Who Are You
One Way Ticket
Nobody Ever Told You
Thank God For Hometowns
Cupid's Got A Shotgun

This was difficult. I love all the songs, even the ones I ranked towards the bottom (WAY and GIG in particular). I tried to base my list off what I listen to most. I listen to the uptempo songs more than the ballads, just because I'm always in the mood for those. Ranking this time was much easier now that the album has sunk in.
 

sgabe_15

New member
1. Do You Think About Me
2. Good in Goodbye
3. Wine After Whiskey
4. Blown Away
5. One Way Ticket
6. Good Girl
7. Forever Changed
8. Nobody Ever Told You
9. Leave Love Alone
10. Two Black Cadillacs
11. See You Again
12. Thank God For Hometowns
13. See You Again
14. Who Are You
 

quincyeyes

Member
1. Blown Away
2. Two Black Cadillacs
3. Wine After Whiskey
4. Good Girl
5. Cupid's Got A Shotgun
6. Leave love Alone
7. See You Again
8. Who Are You
9. One Way Ticket
10. Forever Changed
11. Good in Goodbye
12. Do You Think About Me
13. Nobody Ever Told You
14. Thank God For Hometowns
 

vs758

New member
1. Two black cadillacs
2. Blown away
3. Do you think about me
4. Good girl
5. See you again
6. One way ticket
7. Nobody ever told you
8. Wine after whiskey
9. Good in goodbye
10. Leave love alone
11. Forever changed
12. Who are you
13. Thank god for hometowns
14. Cupids got a shotgun
 

dsfox2009

New member
I think it’s about time that I face my fears and actually attempt to do this :p The list is subject to change, of course, but here goes haha

Cupid’s Got a Shotgun
Wine After Whiskey
Two Black Cadillacs
Good Girl
Blown Away
Do You Think About Me
See You Again
One Way Ticket
Leave Love Alone
Thank God For Hometowns
Nobody Ever Told You
Who Are You
Good In Goodbye
Forever Changed

I’m just go ahead and call this the list, as I continue to keep changing it even after looking at it for a few seconds HAHA!
 

Audra

Active member
I think this list won't change all too much but I never know LOL

Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs
Cupid’s Got a Shotgun
One Way Ticket
Good Girl
Wine After Whiskey
Leave Love Alone
Do You Think About Me
See You Again
Who Are You
Nobody Ever Told You
Good In Goodbye
Forever Changed
Thank God For Hometowns
 

CorayyMac

New member
1.) Good In Goodbye - My favorite on this album by far! It's so raw and emotional.
2.) See You Again - Just love it, very mainstream country and the chorus is amazing! ( SINGLE MATERIAL )
3.) Good Girl - I pretty much love anything Carrie does that's upbeat, lovin' the more "fierce" side of her! ( SINGLE MATERIAL )
4.) Blown Away - Perfect single material, it will do very well & I ALWAYS have it on repeat! ( SINGLE MATERIAL )
5.) Two Black Cadillacs - Very dark and vindictive, LOVE IT! Single material here folks! ( SINGLE MATERIAL )
6.) Thank GOD for Hometowns - This song strikes a chord with me, being a college student and being away, definitely a hit for me!
7.) Forever Changed - I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE the story behind this. It's another ( Temporary Home ) type of song!
8.) Do You Think About Me - One of those cruising in the country type of songs with the top down on the Jeep!
9.) Nobody Ever Told You - Simple, yet amazing!
10.) One Way Ticket - At first I was like eh, now im listening to it more, yet another summer jam! ( SINGLE MATERIAL "IF" PROMOTED RIGHT & GOOD VID )
11.) Who Are You - Kind of reminds me of Shania Twain when she sings this. LOVE IT!
12.) Wine After Whiskey - Great song, good meaning!
13.) Leave Love Alone - I'm still eh about this song, I have no idea why. Feel like one of those ending credit songs for movies.
14.) Cupids Got A Shotgun - I just can't get into this song, AT ALL, but she sounds amazing on the track!
 
Two Black Cadillacs
Good In Goodbye
Leave Love Alone
Blown Away
See You Again
Do You Think About Me
One Way Ticket
Nobody Ever Told You
Good Girl
Cupid's Got A Shotgun
Thank God For Hometowns
Wine After Whiskey
Who Are You
Forever Changed
 

Burst

Active member
Now:
Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs
See You Again
One Way Ticket
Do You Think About Me
Good Girl
Wine After Whiskey
Who Are You
Good in Goodbye
Cupid's Got a Shotgun
Nobody Ever Told You
Leave Love Alone
Forever Changed

1. Blown Away (=)
2. Two Black Cadillacs (=)
3. Do You Think About Me (+2) It's been really growing on me for the past few weeks. :D
4. One Way Ticket (=)
5. Good Girl (+1)
6. See You Again (-3)
7. Wine After Whiskey (=)
8. Good in Goodbye (+1)
9. Who Are You (-1)
10. Cupid's Got a Shotgun (=)
11. Nobody Ever Told You (=)
12. Forever Changed (+1)
13. Leave Love Alone (-1)
14. Thank God For Hometowns (=)
 
Blown Away Ranking

1. See You Again
2. Blown Away
3. Good Girl
4. Thank God For Hometowns
5. Two Black Cadillacs
6. Nobody Ever Told You
7. One Way Ticket
8. Good In Goodbye
9. Do You Think About Me
10. Wine After Whiskey
11. Forever Changed
12. Cupid's Got a Shotgun
13. Who Are You
14. Leave Love Alone
 

NC State Carrie Fan

Well-known member
This is how much they've changed in 2 1/2 months!
1.Blown Away (+1)
2.See You Again (+3)
3.Two Black Cadillacs (-2)
4.Good Girl (-1)
5.Do You Think About Me (+3)
6.Wine After Whiskey (--)
7.One Way Ticket (+2)
8.Leave Love Alone (-4)
9.Good In Goodbye (+1)
10.Cupids Got A Shotgun (+3)
11.Forever Changed (-4)
12.Thank God For Hometowns (--)
13.Who Are You (-2)
14.Nobody Ever Told You (--)
 
Top