I had to go with "You stole my happy"
Carrie Underwood Fans
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Storyteller Top 3/Bottom 3
- Thread starter Claire2004
- Start date
I had to go with "You stole my happy"
carriethequeen
Well-known member
Wow! I guess I'm in the minority because I love Clock Don't Stop. Honestly I never realized the strange lyrics because I loved the big drums in the chorus and the melody so much, and yes I will give it to you guys, the lyrics are weird on that second verse. But I just loved the melody of the verses so much that I didn't notice it. And the best part of the song is towards the end with those big "yeah" notes...one of the best vocal moments on the album
DizzyDollyDee
Active member
I love Carrie's vocals on every song - even if I'm not fond of the song, her vocals draw me in.
DL is my favorite and Mexico (today) is my last choice - but things change up - my favorites have always stayed the same but RR sometimes hits the bottom also. Funny how we all pick different ones. I'm thrilled she is doing HB on the radio (if I could just hear it more) as love everything about it!
DL is my favorite and Mexico (today) is my last choice - but things change up - my favorites have always stayed the same but RR sometimes hits the bottom also. Funny how we all pick different ones. I'm thrilled she is doing HB on the radio (if I could just hear it more) as love everything about it!
carriefan14
Well-known member
Top 3:
1. Dirty Laundry
2. Church Bells
3. Like I'll never love you again
Bottom 3:
1. The Girl You Think I Am
2. Relapse
3. Clock Don't Stop
1. Dirty Laundry
2. Church Bells
3. Like I'll never love you again
Bottom 3:
1. The Girl You Think I Am
2. Relapse
3. Clock Don't Stop
AdamLikesCarrie
Well-known member
Top 3:
1. Dirty Laundry
2. Heartbeat
3. Renegade Runaway
Bottom 3:
1. Clock Don't Stop
2. Like I'll Never Love You Again
3. Chaser (tough one)
1. Dirty Laundry
2. Heartbeat
3. Renegade Runaway
Bottom 3:
1. Clock Don't Stop
2. Like I'll Never Love You Again
3. Chaser (tough one)
showheryoucare
Active member
Top 3:
1. Choctaw County Affair
2. Dirty Laundry
3. What I Never Knew I Always Wanted
Bottom 3
1. Clock Don't Stop
2. Heartbeat (Sam Hunt version)
3. Relapse
1. Choctaw County Affair
2. Dirty Laundry
3. What I Never Knew I Always Wanted
Bottom 3
1. Clock Don't Stop
2. Heartbeat (Sam Hunt version)
3. Relapse
Hey Rob nice to see you!
Too funny how CDS is in almost everyone's bottom 3 and that's the one Carrie chooses to sing.
Some times I think she's out of touch with her fans.
I remember a poll on the fc homepage when PO came out of your favorite song on the cd. From start to finish MS was everyone's least fav by a mile so what does she do? Releases it as a single. Go figure.
CarrieUDomination
Member
Mine changed!
TOP 3:
1. Dirty Laundry
2. Chaser
3. Choctaw County Affair
BOTTOM 3:
1. Renegade Runaway
2. Clock Don't Stop
3. What I Never Knew I Always Wanted
None of those are in particular order xD
TOP 3:
1. Dirty Laundry
2. Chaser
3. Choctaw County Affair
BOTTOM 3:
1. Renegade Runaway
2. Clock Don't Stop
3. What I Never Knew I Always Wanted
None of those are in particular order xD
GagaUnderwood
New member
Top 3:
Mexico
Choctaw County Affair
Dirty Laundry
Bottom 3:
Chaser
Relapse
LINLYA
Tbh, I don't dislike any of the songs on Storyteller. These are my picks based purely on how much I actually listen to the tracks.
Mexico
Choctaw County Affair
Dirty Laundry
Bottom 3:
Chaser
Relapse
LINLYA
Tbh, I don't dislike any of the songs on Storyteller. These are my picks based purely on how much I actually listen to the tracks.
AIgrl06
New member
Lol, yess!
Top 3:
1.Like I'll Never Love You Again
2.Relapse
3.Dirty Laundry
Honorable Mention: Clock Don't Stop/Heartbeat
Bottom 3:
1.Renegade Runaway
2.Smoke Break
3.What I Never Knew I Always Wanted
LINLYA has quite possibly grown to become my favorite Carrie Underwood song of all-time, surpassing Two Black Cadillacs and Someday When I Stop Loving You. I think it's BEAUTIFUL. And it's sung with such emotion, I just... ugh. <3
carrie admirer
New member
Top 3:
1.heartbeat
2.church bells
3.renegade runaway
Bottom 3:
1.chaser
2.relapse
3.clock don't stop
1.heartbeat
2.church bells
3.renegade runaway
Bottom 3:
1.chaser
2.relapse
3.clock don't stop
Kizmet311
Active member
Can't recall if I've already done this, but it probably changes all the time anyway, lol. DL/CCA are definitely top 5, but I think these are my current Top 3. WINK used to be bottom 3, but Smoke Break has snuck in instead, I think. WINK would still be bottom 4, though. I loved it in concert, but I think it's lyrically weak and the music is too contemporary/pop sounding.
Top 3:
Church Bells
Chaser
LINLYA
Bottom 3:
Clock Don't Stop
Mexico
Smoke Break
Top 3:
Church Bells
Chaser
LINLYA
Bottom 3:
Clock Don't Stop
Mexico
Smoke Break
RyanVaCarrieFan
Active member
Top 3
1.) Church Bells
2.) Dirty Laundry
3.) Choctaw County Affair
Bottom 3
1.) Heartbeat
2.) Smoke Break
3.) Renegade Runaway
Order of all songs from favorite to least favorite
1.) Church Bells
2.) Dirty Laundry
3.) Choctaw County Affair
4.) LINLYA
5.) Relapse
6.) The Girl You Think I Am
7.) Chaser
8.) Mexico
9.) WINKIW
10.) Clock Don't Stop
11.) Heartbeat
12.) Smoke Break
13.) Renegade Runaway
1.) Church Bells
2.) Dirty Laundry
3.) Choctaw County Affair
Bottom 3
1.) Heartbeat
2.) Smoke Break
3.) Renegade Runaway
Order of all songs from favorite to least favorite
1.) Church Bells
2.) Dirty Laundry
3.) Choctaw County Affair
4.) LINLYA
5.) Relapse
6.) The Girl You Think I Am
7.) Chaser
8.) Mexico
9.) WINKIW
10.) Clock Don't Stop
11.) Heartbeat
12.) Smoke Break
13.) Renegade Runaway
Burst
Well-known member
This changed a little I guess.
1. Relapse
2. Chaser
3. Heartbeat
4. Church Bells
5. Dirty Laundry
6. Mexico
7. Choctaw County Affair
8. Like I'll Never Love You Again
9. Renegade Runaway
10. The Girl You Think I Am
11. What I Never Knew I Always Wanted
12. Clock Don't Stop
13. Smoke Break
stayed the same
full order
1.Chaser
2.DL
3.CCA
4.CB
5.SB
6.WINK
7.HB
8.Relapse
9.LINLYA
10.TGYTIA
11.RR
12.Mexico
13.CDS
late to the game but just noticed the first 3 singles all have to letter abbreviations ending in B
mtreasmith
Active member
TOP
CCA
DL
Relapse
BOTTOM
SmB
CDS
WINKIAW
Mine changed a tad. Here is my old one:
Top 3
Relapse
Chaser
CCA
*honorable mention* Mexico
Bottom 3
Smoke Break
WINKIAW
CDS
CCA
DL
Relapse
BOTTOM
SmB
CDS
WINKIAW
Mine changed a tad. Here is my old one:
Top 3
Relapse
Chaser
CCA
*honorable mention* Mexico
Bottom 3
Smoke Break
WINKIAW
CDS
tgbrinker
Well-known member
Top
-Church Bells
-Choctaw
-Mexico
(Heartbeat and Dirty Laundry sometimes swap in too)
Bottom
-Chaser
-Clock Don't Stop
-Little Girl Don't Grow Up Too Fast
Update:
Top
-Church Bells
-Choctaw
-Mexico
(Heartbeat, Dirty Laundry, Renegade, and Smoke Break all swap in depending on the day)
Bottom
-Clock Don't Stop
-Little Girl
-The Girl You Think I Am
(Chaser finally grew on me - still towards the bottom)