Carrie Underwood Fans

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Top 3 songs from each album!

countrymusicfan15

Well-known member
What are everyone’s top 3 favorite songs from each album?? And you can only use an honorable mention or tie for one album so use it wisely lol 😝 I’ll go first!

SH:
Don’t Forget To Remember Me
Wasted
Lessons Learned

CR:
Get Out Of This Town
So Small
Wheel Of The World

PO: (this is where I’ll use my one honorable mention)
Cowboy Casanova
This Time
Someday When I Stop Loving You
Quitter

BA:
See You Again
Good Girl
Do You Think About Me

Storyteller:
Renegade Runaway
Dirty Laundry
Chaser

CP:
Ghosts On The Stereo
Low
Cry Pretty

D&R:
Velvet Heartbreak
Denim & Rhinestones
Crazy Angels
 

ChoctawCountyAffair

Well-known member
Oh god, this is so hard

SH: Before He Cheats, Wasted (top 5 ever for me), That's Where It Is

CR: I Told You So (also top 5, the perfect country ballad), Just a Dream, Get Out of This Town

Play On: Someday When I Stop Loving You (it should've been a single), Cowboy Casanova, What Can I Say

Blown Away: Blown Away, Two Black Cadillacs (we need part 2), Good in Goodbye

Storyteller: THE album for me. It's hard to only choose 3. Church Bells, CCA, Like I'll Never Love You Again
Special mention: Relapse, Chaser, TGYTIA, the entire album basically

Cry Pretty: Spinning Bottles, Backsliding, Drinking Alone

D&R: Burn, Wanted Woman, She Don't Know
 

DirtyLaundry

Active member
SH:
Before He Cheats
Wasted
Lessons Learned

CR:
I Know You Won’t
I Told You So
Last Name

PO:
Cowboy Casanova
Look At Me
What Can I Say

BA:
Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs
Good Girl
HM: Forever Changed

Storyteller:
Church Bells
Relapse
Dirty Laundry

CP:
Drinking Alone
Spinning Bottles
Low

D&R:
Burn
She Don’t Know
Velvet Heartbreak

This was hard! But these are the songs I seem to go back to the most and are just sort of timeless. Had the toughest time choosing for Storyteller and Blown Away.
 
Last edited:

CU4ever

Well-known member
* listed in order with #1 being my favorite

Some Hearts:
1. Jesus, Take the Wheel
2. Starts With Goodbye
3. Whenever You Remember

Carnival Ride:
1. All American Girl
2. Just a Dream
3. So Small

Play On:
1. What Can I Say
2. Someday When I Stop Loving You
3. Look at Me

Blown Away:
1. Good in Goodbye
2. Who Are You
3. Blown Away
*honorable mention: Wine After Whiskey

Storyteller:
1. Like I'll Never Love You Again
2. Heartbeat
3. Smoke Break

Cry Pretty:
1. Backsliding (underrated!)
2. Cry Pretty
3. Southbound

Denim & Rhinestones
1. Burn
2. Crazy Angels
3. Faster

The hardest albums for me were Blown Away, Storyteller, and D&R. Love sooo many on those! The earlier ones were rather easy where I knew my favorites easily.

And for fun...

My Gift:
1. Favorite Time of Year
2. Silent Night
3. Hallelujah

My Savior:
1. Softly and Tenderly
2. How Great Thou Art
3. Amazing Grace
 

NC State Carrie Fan

Well-known member
Some Hearts:
Wasted
Jesus, Take The Wheel
Before He Cheats

Carnival Ride:
So Small
Last Name
You Won't Find This

Play On:
Cowboy Casanova
Someday When I Stop Loving You
This Time
Honorable Mention: Mama's Song

Blown Away:
Good Girl
Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs

Storyteller:
Church Bells
Mexico
Heartbeat

Cry Pretty:
Backsliding
Southbound
End Up With You

Denim & Rhinestones
She Don't Know
Denim & Rhinestones
Hate My Heart

Haters gonna hate but Play On does not get the love it deserves lol. It, Carnival Ride, and D&R are still at the top for me.


My Gift:
Sweet Baby Jesus
Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas
O Holy Night

My Savior:
Because He Lives
Nothing But The Blood of Jesus
Great Is Thy Faithfulness
 

FanSince04

Well-known member
SH:
Some Hearts:
Wasted
Jesus, Take The Wheel
Before He Cheats

Carnival Ride:
So Small
Last Name
You Won't Find This

Play On:
Cowboy Casanova
Someday When I Stop Loving You
This Time
Honorable Mention: Mama's Song

Blown Away:
Good Girl
Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs

Storyteller:
Church Bells
Mexico
Heartbeat

Cry Pretty:
Backsliding
Southbound
End Up With You

Denim & Rhinestones
She Don't Know
Denim & Rhinestones
Hate My Heart

Haters gonna hate but Play On does not get the love it deserves lol. It, Carnival Ride, and D&R are still at the top for me.


My Gift:
Sweet Baby Jesus
Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas
O Holy Night

My Savior:
Because He Lives
Nothing But The Blood of Jesus
Great Is Thy Faithfulness
Completely agree with Play On not getting enough love
 

txacar

Well-known member
Some Hearts:
Before He Cheats
Wasted
Jesus Take the Wheel
Honorable Mention: The Night Before (Life Goes On)

Carnival Ride:
I Told You So
Flat on the Floor
I Know You Won't

Play On:
Cowboy Casanova
What Can I Say
Look at Me

Blown Away:
Wine After Whiskey
Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs

Storyteller:
Smoke Break
Dirty Laundry
Church Bells

Cry Pretty:
Ghosts on the Stereo
Drinking Alone
Low

Denim & Rhinestones:
She Don't Know
Crazy Angels
Burn
 

ChoctawCountyAffair

Well-known member
Some Hearts:
Before He Cheats
Wasted
Jesus Take the Wheel
Honorable Mention: The Night Before (Life Goes On)

Carnival Ride:
I Told You So
Flat on the Floor
I Know You Won't

Play On:
Cowboy Casanova
What Can I Say
Look at Me

Blown Away:
Wine After Whiskey
Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs

Storyteller:
Smoke Break
Dirty Laundry
Church Bells

Cry Pretty:
Ghosts on the Stereo
Drinking Alone
Low

Denim & Rhinestones:
She Don't Know
Crazy Angels
Burn
ohh i forgot about The Night Before (Life Goes On), such a great song
 

LilUnderwood

Well-known member
Some Hearts
Don’t Forget to Remember Me
Lessons Learned
That’s Where It Is

Carnival Ride
So Small
Last Name
Get Out of This Town

Play On
Cowboy Casanova (I’m going to be 90 and still rocking out to this one)
Unapologize
Someday When I Stop Loving You

Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs
Wine After Whiskey
Cupid’s Got A Shotgun

Storyteller
Renegade Runaway
Choctaw County Affair
Mexico

Cry Pretty
Ghosts on the Stereo
Low
End up with You

Denim and Rhinestones
Hate My Heart
Poor Everybody Else
Velvet Heartbreak
Crazy Angels

My Savior
Nothing but the Blood of Jesus
Victory in Jesus
Softly and Tenderly
 

maddkat

Staff member
Moderator
Some Heart:
BHC
The Night Before
DFTRM

Carnival Ride:
You Won't Find This
So Small
Last Name

Play On:
Cowboy Casanova
Quitter
Songs Like This
honorable mention - What Can I say

Blown Away:
Blown Away
Good in Goodbye
See You Again

Storyteller:
Church Bells
CCA
WINK

Cry Pretty:
Spinning Bottles
Low
Backsliding

Denim & Rhinestones:
Faster
Poor Everybody Else
She Don't Know

My Gift:
Hallelujah
O Holy Night
Little Drummer Boy

My Savior:
Victory in Jesus
Nothing But the Blood
Softly and Tenderly
 

Smokyiiis

Well-known member
Some Hearts:

Wasted
Before He Cheats
Starts With Goodbye

Carnival Ride:

I Know You Won’t
Last Name
I Told You So

Play On:

Some Day When I Stop Loving You
What Can I Say?
Look At Me

Blown Away:

Two Black Cadillacs
Blown Away
Wine After Whiskey

Storyteller:

Choctaw County Affair
Dirty Laundry
Church Bells

Cry Pretty:

Spinning Bottles
Ghosts on the Stereo
Drinking Alone
Low

Denim & Rhinestones:

Faster
Poor Everybody Else
Pink Champagne

My Gift:

Hallelujah
Mary Did You Know
Little Drummer Boy

My Savior:

Nothing But The Blood Of Jesus
Victory In Jesus
Amazing Grace

VERY VERY VERY HARD to pick only three from the majority of these albums! Definitely could NOT from Cry Pretty....REFUSED.
 

montdu39

Well-known member
1. JTTW
2. That’s Where It Is
3. Wasted

1. So Small
2. Just A Dream
3. Last Name

1. Cowboy Casanova
2. Someday When I Stop Loving You
3. Change

1. Blown Away
2. Two Black Cadillacs
3. Wine After Whiskey or See You Again

1. Church Bells
2. Heartbeat
3. Mexico

1. Cry Pretty
2. Backsliding
3. Spinning Bottles

1. Ghost Story
2. Burn
3. Velvet Heartbreak
 

Carrie_Hannah

Well-known member
SH:
I Just Can’t Live A Lie
Whenever You Remember
That’s Where It Is

CR:
So Small
You Won’t Find This
Twisted

PO:
What Can I Say
Play On
Unapologize

BA:
Good In Goodbye
Wine After Whiskey
Thank God For Hometowns

Storyteller:
What I Never Knew I Always Wanted
Heartbeat
Chaser

CP:
Backsliding
Spinning Bottles
Low

D&R:
Burn
Wanted Woman
Denim & Rhinestones


I’m a deep track type of fan 🤷🏼‍♀️❤️
 

lizcarlo

Well-known member
This is going to be hard especially on certain cd's

SH:
Don’t Forget to Remember Me
Wasted
Jesus Take the Wheel

CR:
Flat On the Floor
I Know You Won't
Just A Dream

PO:
Someday When I Stop Loving You
Look At Me
Temporary Home

BA:
Forever Changed
Blown Away
Two Black Cadillacs

Storyteller:
Choctaw County Affair
Like I'll Never Love You Again
Church Bells

CP:
Cry Pretty
Low
Spinning Bottles

D&R:
Pink Champagne
She Don't Know
Faster

My Gift:
Joyful, Joyful, We Adore Thee
Little Drummer Boy (Feat. Isaiah Fisher)
Favorite Time of Year

My Savior:
Soft and Tenderly
The Old Rugged Cross
Nothing But the Blood of Jesus
 
Last edited:
Top