Carrie Underwood Fans

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Your fave Carrie album though the years??

Your fave Carrie album though the years since American Idol??


  • Total voters
    8
  • Poll closed .

NC State Carrie Fan

Well-known member
1. Carnival Ride
2. Cry Pretty
3. Play On (close to CP)
4. Storyteller
5. Blown Away
6. Some Hearts

PO is such an underrated album in my opinion
 

Zach1998

Well-known member
1. Storyteller
2. Carnival Ride
3. Blown Away
4. Some Hearts
5. Play On
6. Cry Pretty

Commentary: Carnival Ride and Blown Away are very close to each other, but I gave Carnival Ride the slight edge.
 

gocountrymusic

Active member
I am flip-flopping between Carnival Ride and Storyteller right now
(1) Storyteller
(2) Carnival Ride
(3) Cry Pretty
(4) Blown Away
(5) Play On
(6) Some Hearts
 

Eder Rodrigues

Well-known member
1. Storyteller (cohesive, great storyline and single choices)
2. Cry Pretty (Impressive vocals, but in second just because it was Carrie's first co-produced album)
3. Carnival Ride (Great sophomore album, more mature, Carrie showcases her writting and vocals a lot more)
4. Blown Away (An album defined by her singles, the rest was always out of that dark vibe/context for me)
5. Play On (Underated, awful single choices)
6. Some Hearts (Great first album, good single choices, a lot of songs with potencial, but it just doesn't sound like Carrie)
 

FanSince04

Well-known member
1. Storyteller (cohesive, great storyline and single choices)
2. Cry Pretty (Impressive vocals, but in second just because it was Carrie's first co-produced album)
3. Carnival Ride (Great sophomore album, more mature, Carrie showcases her writting and vocals a lot more)
4. Blown Away (An album defined by her singles, the rest was always out of that dark vibe/context for me)
5. Play On (Underated, awful single choices)
6. Some Hearts (Great first album, good single choices, a lot of songs with potencial, but it just doesn't sound like Carrie)
1. Some Hearts
2. Play On
3. Blown Away
4. Carnival Ride
5. Cry Pretty
6. Storyteller

1a. My Savior
2a. My Gift
 

BlownAway14

Member
1. Storyteller
2. Blown Away
3. Cry Pretty
4. Some Hearts
5. Carnival Ride
6. Play On
Since she released two more albums and my taste changed a bit here is my updated version of her discography.
1. Blown Away
2. Storyteller
3. Cry Pretty
4. Carnival Ride
5. Some Hearts
6. My Savior
7. My Gift
8. Play On
 

LilUnderwood

Well-known member
For now as I have been listening to her discography getting ready for CU7 I would say my ranking is:
1. Storyteller
2. My Savior
3. Blown Away
4. Cry Pretty/ Play On
5. Carnival Ride/ Some Hearts

I had two ties at the bottom because they seem equal in their standing to me!
 
Top