Your ideal Idol judging panel

[AnthonyLovesCarrie]

If you could choose any 3 or 4 celebs to be judges on American Idol, who would you choose?

I think Shania Twain was a great guest judge. Although I am happy with new panel, except I sort of feel like they should've gotten rid of Randy too, to start over completely fresh.

I think Steven Tyler, Jennifer Lopez, Shania Twain, and maybe P. Diddy would be an interesting judging panel. I also think LeAnn Rimes would be a good judge.

 

[conorlovescarrie:)]

I loved Simon, Paula and Randy, maybe its just because it was the original panel, but I loved them, especially Simon and Paula