Who's the best Idol ever?

[carebear4eva]

Another one of those blasted "Who's the best Idol ever?" posts that lists Kelly as number one. Feel free to go leave your dirty comments, lol! You don't need to create an account or anything of the sort, just type your comment, select "Post as" choose "Guest", give your email id, and your good......Go defend our girl there people!

Who's the Top 'American Idol' of All-Time?

 

[supercarriefan]

I don't know why websites feel the need to keep this Kelly vs. Carrie nonsense going. I'm not leaving a comment because I'm a fan of both women...sorry. They didn't say anything that bashed Carrie, so no need to start drama with Kelly's fans about this.
I don't get why people have to say one is better...it doesn't matter...they are both highly successful, and are incredibly talented.

 

[utlovescarrie]

It's annoying. It is also (based on what they claim makes Kelly #1) wrong. Carrie has her bet in those.

 

[Pi314CA]

It is annoying but I guess this creates hits on their website. A few more CDs from Carrie and the comparison will be more clearcut.

 

[carebear4eva]

Yeah, that's a good point. Kelly is becoming old news fast, while Carrie's fan base is expanding (although the album sales don't prove it, the touring does). I just really want Carrie to pull a Shania and Come on Over and go international soon.