Cry Pretty Album Reviews

[CarrieAddicted]

CP is not even listed on Metacritic.

Odd

 

[AngeloUnderwood]

For now we have 40/100 (The Guardian), 70/100 (Rolling Stone) and 90/100 (Allmusic). The Time (UK) doesn't count for metacritic, thank God. As for LA Times, I hope that thing lumping together two albums doesn't count

 

[CarrieAddicted]

For now we have 40/100 (The Guardian), 70/100 (Rolling Stone) and 90/100 (Allmusic). The Time (UK) doesn't count for metacritic, thank God. As for LA Times, I hope that thing lumping together two albums doesn't count

I believe the review by TIME magazine (US) counts too.

 

[teesharky]

Washington post loves it!! That’s a big paper! I tweeted it but I am
bit able to post it here right now.

 

[teesharky]

For now we have 40/100 (The Guardian), 70/100 (Rolling Stone) and 90/100 (Allmusic). The Time (UK) doesn't count for metacritic, thank God. As for LA Times, I hope that thing lumping together two albums doesn't count

Does The Washington Post count? They loved it!

 

[Smokyiiis]

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...ill-makes-a-statement/?utm_term=.8a98f7902691

 

[Smokyiiis]

CP is not even listed on Metacritic.

Odd

https://www.metacritic.com/music/cry-pretty/carrie-underwood

 

[CarrieAddicted]

Does The Washington Post count? They loved it!

Their movie, TV and games reviews do count, but I couldn't find their music reviews on Metacritic.

ODD

 

[CarrieAddicted]

Reviewers that count, based on other albums I've seen:

Rolling Stone
AllMusic
The Independent (UK)
Sputnickmusic
Spin
Consequence of Sound
Variety
Pitchfork
Boston Globe
Chicago Tribune
LA Times
The Guardian
Austin Chronicle
Record Collector
No Ripcord
Uncut
Under the Radar
New York Times
Entertainment Weekly
The Telegraph
Exclaim
Pop Matters
Slant Magazine
Billboard
Country Weekly

 

[Smokyiiis]

Wish they would get that Sputnickmusic one up on the metacritic to slam that Guardian one. What a creep!

 

[Smokyiiis]

So far she's at 68. Users get busy writing and posting your reviews! I did mine.

 

[teesharky]

Yes everyone review it on metacrituc!

She will rise from 68 soon as the two snarkiest reviews are up so once the positive ones are added it will help.

 

[Smokyiiis]

Post your reviews here:

ttps://www.metacritic.com/music/cry...rrie-underwood

 

[teesharky]

I am having trouble figuring out how to leave a review on metacrituc? I never had issues before. Is there a place to click a link to write a review? Thsnks

 

[AngeloUnderwood]

Wish they would get that Sputnickmusic one up on the metacritic to slam that Guardian one. What a creep!

Unfortunately that review was made by an user, not the critic, so it doesn't count

 

[teesharky]

We need reviews from
Billboard and EW . Those should hopefully be positive.

 

[AngeloUnderwood]

We need reviews from
Billboard and EW . Those should hopefully be positive.

Billboard doesn't count anymore for metacritic, even though I never understood why ahah
EW should be positive

 

[Smokyiiis]

Tee click on User reviews and once your logged in should be able to review it. Mine went up instantly.

 

[teesharky]

Thanks! How odd that Billboatd doesn’t count anymore. It used to. That sucks. It leaves a lot room for osnarky small blogs and haters to go after her.

 

[Smokyiiis]

We need a LOT of positive USER reviews. Two people posted 0 out of 10 in user reviews that are obviously not Carrie fans. Have to bring the score up. They do this every album cycle.