I like the new judging panel a lot more than I thought I would. Simon's little act was getting old, and honestly, he started boring me the last season or 2. I'm glad we got 2 new fresh judges, and I think J-Lo is like the new Paula, except better. And at least we have a true musician in Steven Tyler, who actually knows what he is talking about.
It seems like they're trying to force Randy into the new Simon role, which I don't like. I think Randy should just be himself. I love Randy's laugh though, it's so contagious. Although I think it may have been better if they would have gotten rid of him as well, so that way they have all new judges and can start over fresh. But I don't mind Randy too much, and at least he has chemistry with Steven and Jennifer.
I do sort of miss Kara though. I thought she was a good judge, gave good advice, and always seemed very knowledgeable. She annoyed me at times, but she was a good judge.
For next season, I wouldn't mind them adding a 4th judge again, and maybe bring Kara back or bring in another female like Shania Twain. For some reason, I also think LeAnn Rimes would make a good judge.