Agree. I think AI was too much about advancing/reviving careers of the judges, than the judges actually truly judging the contestants.
I hope they start with a whole new panel of judges who will judge all contestants fairly and equally, including providing constructive criticism so they can improve on their talent. And please, let them end all the drama at the judges' table!
If they can't get back to where the show began, I think they should scrap it. It's been too biased and too predictable for years.
I actually didn't find there to be too much drama amongst the judges the past 2 years. I think that in terms of chemistry on the panel Steven, Jennifer and Randy had the best overall from all the seasons.
There was far more drama on the panel when Simon was around because he was always trying to get on Paula's nerves.
I think the judges' drama was at its worst when Kara was around in seasons 8 and 9. She has a very harsh personality, and it didn't seem to blend well with the panel.
I think the show has always been biased. Right from the beginning, the judges have always had people they favored. The issue in the last two seasons is that the judges have been uneven in their praise. They are over the top with some contestants (Joshua this season, Scotty last season for example) while making others really have to work for it (Hollie this season). They also would critique certain people for things one week, yet praise them for that very thing the next week (Phillip with his changing of melodies).
A judging panel that could at least be consistent would be nice lol.