There is no baby crying. x) That's just some string instrument. Sooo, change your vote, Tee!
First, it is your opinion that the song is average, and the songwriting is poor. It is not fact. Sorry if that sounds harsh, but your comments came across as though you were stating it as a fact. Stating that it is "vastly inferior to TH" is a bit much, IMO.
I happen to think this song is beautiful, and I can certainly relate. I am dealing with my grandmother and grandfather's dementia right now, and that last verse makes me cry every single time I hear it. We are dealing with them not knowing us, thinking deceased relatives are visiting, etc.
Just because your family doesn't feel any emotional connection to the song doesn't mean that many others going through a similar experience won't feel something. The emotion I feel when I hear this song isn't forced. It comes naturally because the lyrics remind me so much of my grandparents' life together from their courtship to having their children, and finally to where they are now dealing with illness.
I agree with this 100%. I'm not even going through something like this, and I always feel like I'm gonna break down when I hear Forever Changed.
I don't think the lyrics are forced at all. They take you to another time, another place. I love that. You feel like you're transported into a totally different world until reality punches you in the gut during the final verse. I won't even talk about Carrie's delivery since I think we can all agree that this is at least one of her best vocal performances ever, and if not, well, that's fine. It's your opinion. But I honestly believe it's her best vocal performance of all-time. This is the only performance that can compete with How Great Thou Art. Maybe they can be co-champions.
I'm rambling. Anyway, I just love that the song is so simple, yet it's so
loaded. It's like a Nutella sandwich. It's nothing much from a technical standpoint, just bread and Nutella, but when you take a bit out of it, your tastebuds just go berserk.
[Edit] Not that I'm biased or anything.