I thought the treatment was effective - it gave a good visual run through of the song, while interspersing that with the booth scenes (I thought Carrie looked fantastic as the girl in the booth - that was one of my favourite "looks" - more so, for me, than the stage look, though the latter was fully in line with the "high glam" persona that Carrie often adopts). I don't really think the booth scenes could have been more extended. The lyric doesn't develop much detail, and what it does give was shown, Keeping those scenes relatively short enabled them to be presented with an element of enigma. The enigma wasn't resolved - and that may annoy some - but I found it intriguing, and I tend to like videos that leave some room for guessing. The picture the guy burns seems to be of him and the girl he's now sitting in the booth with. That would mean they are not strangers - which does depart from the lyric, but adds to the mystery. (Unfortunately, I couldn't properly see what the girl burns in the ending - YouTube chose that moment to throw in pictures of upcoming videos, which obscured the detail. I expect a clearer version will surface somewhere).
A couple of details I liked - Mark playing traditional bass (I give props for that in a Mainstream video, and I think it makes up for having to play down the dobro for radio); and choosing a Louisville Bourbon (which, for me anyway, both provides a link back to her breakout hit, BHC - and an antidote to the rather overdone attention paid to Tennessee whiskey in songs)